If they aren't in your capital Duchy I wouldn't bother keeping them. (even if you aren't actually interested in a fabricated claim) Park your spymaster in the same county as your heir. As the title says, I'm looking for a way to revoke the city in my newly…The target vassal in question is a tribal ruler, and is NOT allowed to hold a temple (wrong holding type just like you). Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Development Studio. You're only to rule castles, which shouldn't be giving you wrong holding type notifications. Is there any way or maybe a mod out there that reduces the penalty for holding a wrong type of holding. Aug 12, 2015. i'm now getting a "holder is of the wrong holding type"-message. Barons have baronies, mayors have cities, and bishops have bishoprics. The same thing happened 100 years ago when I was king of just Ireland and teld on to Beanaomh in Scotland with the capital. Therefore, it would make sense to replace them with generic 'town', which could be upgraded all the way from 'hamlet' to 'city'. - Cut Baar Dau Holy Site for Baandari Code. Dear CK2 players, Somehow one of my county capitals is a city. On a side note, I think few major patches ago, they changed feudal to theocracy vassal. how do I change it so the county is controlled by the castle? (i know how to change the owners of the wrong demense type, but in current format I can only gove the. CK2 How to's ; What Is The Best Way To Fix The Holder Is Wrong Holding Type In Crusader Kings 2. Tribal rulers can only hold tribes without penalty, but can easily build new tribes in conquered territory; they can also build temples. r/CrusaderKings • The Archduchy of Burgundy - In the year of our lord 1256 - My Recent Modded Run replicating the glory of the Valois-Burgundy House, a very interesting part of French history :) Loved Replicating the Feast of the Pheasant through Tournaments and Feasts! 1. Yorkie Jul 20, 2013 @ 5:02am. Crusader Kings III. Each County that makes up your personal domain is divided up into a number of Baronies. It dictates the available succession laws and holdings of a character, and some government types have unique. 3 What OS are you playing on? Windows What platform are you. That way, if you convert a bishopric to a city, it will still have a great cathedral in it and could more easily be converted back to a bishopric. I'm playing a small count in Germany (Altmark), and after acquiring Mecklenburg from the pagans I am faced with various problems. So im still not understanding this right. If you want to get rid of this hit, change it to a county. How to fix holder is of wrong type. Seize the advantage if the realm is on the Silk Road. Crusader Kings. ck3 with notepad++. How to destroy hospitals? MyFaceBurns. The wrong holding type could then apply with -50% to these other type buildings only. You can move the text by dragging and dropping the Text Element anywhere on the page. . So im still not understanding this right. NapoleonI. Easiest solution for your problem is to save up ~800 gold and build a castle holding there. ) Castles are holdings held primarily by feudal lords. Does everyone go with all cities or all baronies in their capitol? By building all baronies and holding them yourself, you can use your martial and steward to boost your income more than the cities would give you with a large tax rate, and you'll have huge levies (in a good 6 holding capital, more than 10k troops from a single province). My. . No matter who I grant cities to, it is the wrong holding type. You can basically hand the title to any landable character in your court. Step3: Give away the. Is it possible to change this city into a castle so the wrong holding type penalty will disappear?Search titles only. If it is the holding of a vassal, I don't think you can change their holding. Temple. In Negev, for example, you don't get much benefit from Petra because Petra is in Baidha-Petra, which is a City Holding (and until Merchant Republics come out, you won't get any benefit from it at all, just like the Doge's Palace in Venice). Game Version: 1. The game installs a mayor, but he is actually regarded as a castle owner. If I give it to someone else, I get the "wrong government type" relations penalty. Because whenever I assign a landed title I see the levy is. Is the only way. Frustratingly, clicking on the notifier takes me to a "Realm" window which. . . There is a console. If I recall CK2 allowed for you to change holding type (possibly through console commands, though I can't remember exactly). Latest. YOUR CART. Grrrrrrrr. Here is a tip to make murdering him a little easier. Capitals change when the Count/Prince-Bishop/Lord Mayor has direct control of a holding of his own type. I have a lot of CK2 experience but only relatively recently got The Republic. #1. My vassal declared war for a prvince (Don't know how he did that either) and now it says he has the wrong holding type. . So im still not understanding this right. Holy war - usurp the entire target duchy. . Crusader Kings III - Bug Report (Archive) CK III - Wrong capital holding type for a county. . As Poland, I conquered the Pommeranian tribes to the north. Or Tribals don't have castles but Tribes instead. Construct a building in a special holding (hospital, fort or trade post). It is so infuriating when you take a large county with many holdings slot only to find it fill with some ridiculous set up like 4/6 castle or 3/5 temple holding. the only way to really avoid the penalty is to build a tribal holding in one of the empty slots if it is available. 'Wrong Type of Holding' = SO CONFUSED. Because whenever I assign a landed title I see the levy is. Within each barony you can build a single Holding. . Is there a way to change a holding type? Like, changing a city into a castle. I'm a Norse Tribal Jarl, and captured a feudal county. The rule for building new holdings is that the county needs to have 1 of each holding before you can build a second holding of the same type. Therefore, every count who holds this city gets a wrong holding type penalty of -30 (!) with me being a lord. Reply. There are three types of holdings: Baronies: Focus on troops. Here’s a. . Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. So I did just that, and experienced an immediate income drop! Opening up the build-menu in each holding I can't see what' so unusual about them. A Screenshot of Crusader Kings III. You have to get advantage of this to gain Prestige (very important) and gold, via waging wars and raiding. You now hold all counties in the duchy, and all titles beneath those counties. I just managed to take Rome from the Pope, but the papacy has littered the county with temples. Pillaging a temple could be a solution, as temple vassals are pretty much useless for tribals. Kurthakon the creator of this mod has passed away in real life. Crusader Kings 2 Holder is Wrong Holding Type. Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Development Studio. You can even grant duchies (even kingdoms once you're an empire) to them. - Added title history commands 'name', 'adjective', 'reset_name' and 'reset_adjective'. Having trouble with ‘The Holder is Wrong Holding Type’ in Crusader Kings 2? Modifying the save file is a great solution! Here’s how: Locate and open the saved game file, but. Without it being the wrong holding type. Just had a change of leaders, for some reason one of my demenses changed from the castle (barony) being the main title, to a city. You can see it has a city as county capital but it's held by a duke (noble) so it's the wrong type of holding. So I reformed the Germanic religion, then the head dies and I am now the head of the religion setting my government type to ~LANDLESS~ and now Ive got a problem because literally every holding is of the wrong type now for me. The conditions have been chosen to follow the logic of. The Clans screen will indicate. You can switch the names, if you want. The main holding, Ravenna, is a Temple. PK SPACE JAM. Folks, another clueless newbie question: in my current game, I am getting more cash than I'm used to, so I've been improving cities in my demesne left and right. Feb 21, 2012. Then go into the commons folder. This makes him the "wrong holding type" who doesn't earn anything. This way you will not have the Wrong Holding Type penalty. I gave away the bishopric that I took over, but I still have it and it says that the Chiefdom of Gwynedd is the wrong holding type for me. ago. In that case the other holding becomes the capital and the type of the province changes to match the new capital (and the character). I don't know why it's there. You're going to suffer from the 'Wrong government' opinion malus for that particular vassal, but it's still better than holding on to it yourself. Because whenever I assign a landed title I see the levy is decreased due to their low martial skill (-45. I'm not sure for a Mac but, you're going to have to to go your folder that has your game. Except I can't create a new vassal, unlike when you conquer Bishoprics/Cities, so the only option is to give it away to an already existing character. BluePear0 • 3 yr. . It is so frustrating when your baron/mayor/priest level vassal start the wrong. The game is called Crusader Kings and people forget that religion is not the only aspect of the game that suffer from flanderization and misrepresentation outside Europe. My Crusader Kings II guides: The definitive bloodline breeding guide Creating the Tsardom of Russia. I have over 110 hours in Crusader Kings 2, and still have some questions. . A castle town (level 1) costs 130-140 and give you an income of 2 gold (~=70 years), while castle walls can't even compete, costing 70 gold for an income of 0. txt file located Cant seem to find it anywhere. So I'm a bit of a ck noob, 000's of hours in other paradox games tho and I love my…Yes, riding is better in many situation, but you may need desperately a hundred or two ducats just to create Empire title or smite some artifacts. It is very misleading. But nomadic holding doesn't provide any gold anyway and does provide levies only if you stack modifiers really high, so it is not a problem. Sounds like you're tribal and the holding is feudal. There are already mechanics for destroying holdings, for raids. So im still not understanding this right. Going into the holding menu shows that it's labeled a barony but has the buildings of a city. This process is intricate but necessary to ensure seamless gameplay and avoid errors. In CK2, iirc, your holdings that were not of your type (cities and temples) would only give you a fraction of troops and taxes. . Each city you give is +20 relation. I'm pretty sure there are no automatic conversions between tribal and feudal character types or holding types. As the title says, is there a way to destroy hospitals? I'm a nomad and I conquered a county with one in it, and it's annoying considering it's telling me I'm of the 'wrong holding type' yet I can't do anything about it. Fully recommend the Norman conquest. It is easier to make a republic by holy war against other religion than claims against own religion. Thanks in advance! How to destroy hospitals? MyFaceBurns. Select the barony. It is a church. This will only work for the subholdings, so for the main holding you're going to have to either give it away to someone else or create a tribal holding in one. In CK3 it seems to me that you get full levies and taxes for almost any type of holding? I went into a county with a castle as a main holding and a temple as a secondary holding, which I both held myself. I now have a penelty for wrong demense type. You can appoint a courtier to to be the mayor, even a courtier in the court of one of your vassals (a good way to steal one with good stats for a general or for your council). Sep 01, 2020 Crusader Kings III has a ton of content in it. Redirect page. Tribalism is an early form of government, and one of three playable non-feudal government types in CK2 (the other two being merchant republics and nomadism . I just won 3 counties in a war. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. Grant him the county and he'll be lord mayor of Genoa. . Of course, that would probably also require the buildings to be reworked to give different boni, etc. Barons have baronies, mayors have cities, and bishops have bishoprics. New save game recommended, save game compatible. Click on the county you want to be your capital and it's a pointy gold icon. I got this message when I revoked the title of major of Sigtuna (a city) from an underling. This includes Cities of Wonders 2, which we've previously featured and introduces a fourth type of holding – the metropolis. Because whenever I assign a landed title I see the levy is. You're a feudal lord and he is a pesant, so he will always have a opinion hit towards you. . Mastur Ch33f Sep 19, 2020 @ 1:42am. ck3" to gamestate. The easiest way to do this is to click on a county that has the wrong types of holdings, right-click on the at holdings at the bottom of the county screen and select 'Create new vassal'. Now, I gave the county, in which I desired to have my republic (West Iceland), to the already existing mayor in said county. even when my only holding is a temple I am a count and i get the wrong holding notification . To create the new vassal either nightclick a character and grant them the title, or click the Wrong Type of Holding Pop-Up and rightclick the Holding on the bottom left and press on Create New Vassal. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. I got this message when I revoked the title of major of Sigtuna (a city) from an underling. Where is the religiousevents. 81 Badges. Whether you become feudal or clan depends on whether you're muslim or not. Also applies to the AI as it's a defines tweak, but I have no idea if they'll make use of it in any way. A character is affected by your levy and taxation laws based on their type. . I don't know why it's there. To honor his memory please continue his legacy and please credit him, from his sister. This process is intricate but necessary to ensure seamless gameplay and avoid errors. He holds a county, so I would expect him to grant it to a mayor or create a vassal, but he never does no matter how long I wait and keeps holding the city with the "wrong holding type" penalty. . Or Tribals don't have castles but Tribes instead. ), but they won't hand it down to their successor either. . It is rarely worthwhile to keep settlements for which the player character gets the "Wrong government type" penalty. You need to convert that county too a Feudal Culture to be able to change them from Tribal. 500KG Sep 6, 2020 @ 11:52am. Is it possible to change this city into a castle so the wrong holding type penalty will disappear?I have all of Ireland right now (I'm also King of Eire), and I took over Gwynedd from the Petty Kingdom of Gwynedd, but now I have the wrong holding type in my demesne for some reason. . They'll stay under your duchy as your vassal. Engage in courtly intrigue, dynastic struggles, and holy warfare in mediæval Europe, Africa, the Middle East, India, the steppes and Tibet. I have all of Ireland right now (I'm also King of Eire), and I took over Gwynedd from the Petty Kingdom of Gwynedd, but now I have the wrong holding type in my demesne for some reason. 1. I gave away the bishopric that I took over, but I still have it and it says that the Chiefdom of Gwynedd is the wrong holding type for me. Is it possible to change this city into a castle so the wrong holding type penalty will disappear? Showing 1-10 of 10 comments Falk0. Every county in Crusader Kings II has at least one holding. ago • Edited 8 yr. I gave away the bishopric that I took over, but I still have it and it says that the Chiefdom of Gwynedd is the wrong holding type for me. For that to happen, he has to own both the capital and a holding of his preferred type. Or in your realm if you invite them to your court first. There are a few holdings here and there that imo are the wrong type for whatever reason. The problem is that you must give the title of the Holding to someone else to make that annoying message dissapear. Can i change that? i tried putting a baron to it so he could change it but it didnt work somehow. Side note, I'd like the ability to change a holding type in exchange of a large amount of money and the loss of intra holding "buildings". They can only be granted to people, but when you do they are of the wrong holding type and get in. Hell Ormond might even decide that your war is the perfect time to fight a war of independence and the O'Brien's. I have all of Ireland right now (I'm also King of Eire), and I took over Gwynedd from the Petty Kingdom of Gwynedd, but now I have the wrong holding type in my demesne for some reason. There's a "give title" (I think it's called) option in the bottom left of the UI. These control whether or not the 'Recently Conquered' and 'New Administration' holding modifiers are set on victory. txt file located Cant seem to find it anywhere. So im still not understanding this right. ) Tribal rulers can only hold tribes without penalty, but can easily build new tribes in conquered territory; they can also build temples. Just now, I finished constructing a new city in the county where my ruler resides. Or in your realm if you invite them to your court first. And since I'm a count, I can't have count vassals, so. To create the new vassal either nightclick a character and grant them the title, or click the Wrong Type of Holding Pop-Up and rightclick the Holding on the bottom left and press on Create New Vassal. These holdings provide both income and taxes, and every holding is held by a character. Im playing Jylland, i took Sjaelland easily and then took Mercia through the event which prepares an invasion. was finally able to revoke a few of his titles for heresy, but the new (previously unlanded) owner immediatley took a "wrong holding type" penalty. So im still not understanding this right. Feb 10, 2012. Your Steward and Marshal collecting taxes and increasing levies will give the bonus to ALL of your holdings in the county. And since I'm a count, I can't have count vassals, so. 0 Holding-Government Type Mismatch Game Version 3. Then the son's AI would have generated a mayor for the city, as they usually do. Afterwards, I got the "wrong type of holding" warning, and each holding in the three provinces is labeled with a "recently conquered" modifier for wrong religion, wrong culture, etc. I Googled it and the functionality to replace buildings or holding types is not a thing. Therefore, every count who holds this city gets a wrong holding type penalty of -30 (!) with me being a lord. The levy multiplier from empty county holding spots. This includes city holdings. I gave away the bishopric that I took over, but I still have it and it says that the Chiefdom of Gwynedd is the wrong holding type for me. As far as then not taking the land, that must be a. Engage in courtly intrigue, dynastic struggles, and holy warfare in mediæval Europe, Africa, the Middle East, India, the steppes and Tibet. Dear CK2 players, Somehow one of my county capitals is a city. . If the player's demesne has counties on the Silk Road, castles, temples and cities give increased taxes to the holders of the counties. I have all of Ireland right now (I'm also King of Eire), and I took over Gwynedd from the Petty Kingdom of Gwynedd, but now I have the wrong holding type in my demesne for some reason. Venice is fully upgraded (all six slots already filled). Step1: Get your hands on one of the castles (Depending on your Governmenttype it might also be a city or a tribe, but in this case you are feudal so you may only hold castles personally) Step2: Right click on it and choose "Make county capital". (Some changes/fixes will only be applied to new save games. If you hover over the levies near the lower right, it will pull up details about why that specific holding has that number of troops. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts Log in sign up User account menu 15 ExplanationHow to fix Wrong Holding Type and Wrong Government. I have all of Ireland right now (I'm also King of Eire), and I took over Gwynedd from the Petty Kingdom of Gwynedd, but now I have the wrong holding type in my demesne for some reason. There are already mechanics for destroying holdings, for raids. Barons are affected by feudal ta, mayors are. you can have the city raided, which gives it a 5% chance of being razed. How do i change these into tribes? (since i assume thats what they. However, there is two "wrong type of holdings" problems that I can't seem to figure out. -Cities wrong holding type EDIT: Still huge, so divided into 3 posts, 1 per government type. This command adds the specified amount of prestige to your character. I don't know why it's there. As a King can only hold two Duchies without a large opinion penalty from. either upgrade the tribe (you just need to upgrade the fort, although you get buildings from every two levels of. Once you have it, switch the county capital to that holding and then make your friend the mayor of city of Genoa. Jump to latest Follow Reply. Such holdings may either be counties or baronies. I have already reformed the Germanic faith and am finishing up the last buildings in my tribal holdings. If a character is of the wrong caste, they cannot be granted the holding. Last time we opened by discussing how CKIII attempts to simulate and represent the distinctly personal character of rule and decision-making in the Middle. There are four systems of government feudalism, theocracy, republic and tribal. Then you can pass out the temple holding. But they honestly just won't do enough. Members. I've got this notifier pop up - "Wrong type of holding in demesne". You will still be getting the alert, but there's no actual penalties. There seems to be an issue with promoting mayors, or even council members of mayors, to counts. Basically is there a way for your character to hold a City without the penalty for wrong holding type? So that you can take advantage of the high tax bases of Cities. Apr 10, 2018 @ 1:48pm. Tribal rulers can only hold tribes without. Holding. (duchies) You conquered a duchy. I gave away the bishopric that I took over, but I still have it and it says that the Chiefdom of Gwynedd is the wrong holding type for me. I guess this is due to the capital of the county being a city instead of a castle. I researched all the tribal techs. Therefore, every count who holds this city gets a wrong holding type penalty of -30 (!) with me being a lord. . Porcius • Both of the Roman Empires • 8 yr. It's a wrong holding because the primary holding is either a bishopric or a town and you're a feudal lord. In your tribal holdings, at the bottom near the buildings is a castle icon. You need the compatibility patch. Hi, I was playing as the count of gotland as norse pagan and I have invaded Wessex but because there are castles I get the wrong holding type modifier. Though some people reported that it didn't work for them. Imagine playing a schemer with a "Spy Network" landless holding who builds buildings that expand his intrigue options. Report. A castle holding (albeit one with a unique building to simulate Constantinople's famous walls. I have managed to give it away, thanks for the tip. Wrong holder type. . Choose this theme to customize and add content to. However the problem still persists with it being the primary holding. I gave it to both a normal courtier and (after reloading) a machinist and both got wrong holding type penalties. I have to point out that the best way to prevent a succession is long before a ruler dies. In addition your feudal vassals will all have an. I've played a couple decades as a nomad and I can't seem to get much higher than a 3k horde because whenever I get more than 5 counties. I clicked on the construct new holdings button, but it's still grayed out. It's true, in the county I just took, the castle is held by a baron, while the city is held by me. WolfWhiteFire. I got this message when I revoked the title of major of Sigtuna (a city) from an underling. Where is the religiousevents. I tried changing my capital to a castle but i still get the negative modifier. If you hold the castles personally you get 100% of the tax and levies generated by the holding. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. Can't construct new holding. So im still not understanding this right. I don't know why it's there. I gave away the bishopric that I took over, but I still have it and it says that the Chiefdom of Gwynedd is the wrong holding type for me. I can also raise more levies than I. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. Repeat this until you have given away all the counties you do not want. Look for the ID of the barony you want to change (you have to start the game in debug mode and then hover over the barony on the map and the ID is in purple) Open the gamestate. To do this right click the barony in question and "create vassal". Paradox Forum. . I'm Norway - so I am tribal and then I build a temple. If you are tribal, you can't make use of castles. Gunthah Major. . Not to mention that holding the wrong holding type means you are responsible for uphgrading. top of page. . #6. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. Holding Levy = (Building levy) x (1 + Levy size modifiers) x (1 + Tribal land bonus) Building levy is the sum of: . Feudal characters can hold castles, burghers can hold cities, and. Cities: Focus on tax. If you give it to a vasall you will get at least 45/50% or more percent. . Hey guys, I have a huge problem with wrong holding types. Always something to learn as they say. Your only relative already has two counties and he shouldn't. ), but they won't hand it down to their successor either. Nov 12, 2018 A quick tutorial video demonstrating the basi. Within each barony you can build a single Holding. I don't know why it's there. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. So, there doesn't seem to be any way to make them better, and one holding seems to. you can have the city raided, which gives it a 5% chance of being razed. Because whenever I assign a landed title I see the levy is. Hi My question is, what are the consequences (cons and maybe there are some pros) of having a a wrong holding type or a big demense? From what I know: Cons of having a big demense: - Problems with taxes? Cons of having a wrong holding type: -. Support me on patreon : me a tad of your time and support the channel for free on TAD : I am playing with CK2+ mod and ruler designer - not sure if that matters in this situation. I'll presume you're a feudal lord, and that it's a city or a temple.